Existence is a mystery, not a problem. A problem is outside me and can be solved without my being changed. A mystery encloses the one who asks. Primary reflection breaks the world into objects and functions; secondary reflection recovers participation. Being is not having. Despair is the closing of possibility; hope is not optimism but the refusal to treat the last word as already said. Fidelity is creative: I become myself in remaining available to another. The Other is not the death of my possibilities. Communion is the ordinary place of transcendence. He converted to Catholicism in 1929 and resisted the existentialist label once it meant Sartre.
Content
Being and Having (1935), the metaphysical journal. Homo Viator (1945), hope and the itinerant self. The Mystery of Being (Gifford Lectures, 1950; published 1951). Plays carry the same distinctions into domestic betrayal and fidelity.
Journal and lecture, not system. He distrusts the treatise as a form of having. Examples are musical, familial, mundane. The argument proceeds by distinguishing words until a false unity splits.
Concrete philosophy. He starts from situations — promise, betrayal, family, the body — and refuses both the detached ego and the reduction of the person to a function. Against Sartre he insists that unavailability, not the look, is the fall.
Summary
He does not move original sin. He moves relation. If this branch must answer the descent at the point of the Other, he is the Christian reply: availability instead of project, hope instead of useless passion. If the branch remains the causal history of sin, he stays a footnote to Kierkegaard.
People: Bergson; later the Catholic convert’s reading of Augustine and the mystics; Sartre as the public opponent. Place: Paris throughout. Formative experiences: his mother’s early death; a philosopher’s distrust of the Sorbonne’s idealism; conversion in 1929; the Occupation, which made fidelity and betrayal ordinary rather than theatrical. Cultural events: the interwar fashion of the problem-solving self; 1945, when the label he had used was captured by a philosophy he thought had abolished mystery.
“A problem is something met with which bars my passage. A mystery is something in which I myself am involved.”
“Being is not having.”
Hope is “the availability of a soul… so intimately engaged with experience that it cannot entertain the idea of a final negation.”
Fidelity is creative, not the mere keeping of a contract.
“I am obliged to bear witness, because I hold, as it were, a particle of light.”
No comments:
Post a Comment